lilybyred - OLD - Starry Eyes Am9 To Pm9 Gel Eye Liner - 16 Colors

I like to use this eyeliner for my upper waterline. My eyes get wrinkly and oily easily, and in the past I've had eyeliners smudge on top of my eyes. This one does not smudge! it's easy to use, and feels softer on my eyes compared to the other liners.

Really appreciate how many colors are available in this line. Nice pencil, high quality, worth trying

I got the shade Matt Brown and I love using it to do puppy dog eyeliner! I have always been terrible at doing cat eyeliner because I have almond shaped eyes and they are also slightly hooded. However, this works well with my eye shape and the pen is easy to work with especially for beginners.

Absolutely love this pencil! It's my new favorite and I use it almost every day haha.

It is the best pencil I've ever tried, love the formula and it lasts all day. I would definitely get the other colours too and probably repurchase this one because I use it almost every time I do my make up!

This was my first experience with this particular brand and I had been wanting a lighter brown gel eyeliner and this one looked good to me. I'm very pleased with it! The quality is very nice - I drew on my hand with it right before bed to see how it looked and then when I woke up, the shape I drew was still there, looking largely untouched!

The color looks just like what the color strip on the outside implies - it's a light brown that glides on smoothly and doesn't catch on the eyelid at all. I wanted this particular shade (Caramel Brown) for when I want to wear a very subtle nude eye look and this color is just perfect!

I really love this eyeliner. Great quality, great pigmentation, true to the implied color and reasonably priced for that quality to boot. I may have to try more stuff from this brand in the future because this eyeliner has impressed me so much!

I was looking for a very light brown eyeliner and this was perfect! Since it is so light, it looks very natural and it perfectly defines without drawing too much attention/it's almost not there ;) The texture is also really soft. It doesn't draw as easily on my waterline, but it is waterproof. It has a detachable sharpener at the other end of the pencil and you twist it to extend the tip. Excited to use it more!

Glides on super smoothly. Really love the tone of brown, it is a dark brown espresso color, perfect for everyday. Very easy to use for those new to eyeliner.

This liner has the same consistency as the slim gel eyeliners, very blendable, yet opaque. The color I purchased (matt brown) did have glitter particles in it. It's perfect to use for the waterline and it's a screw pencil, so you don't have to bother with sharpening it.

I first tried this eyeliner when I bought it in Olive Young in Korea, when lilybyred was still a new indie brand. I loved the eyeliner so much - it withstood the entire harsh, freezing Seoul winter, and then some more when I took a trip to the dry, sweltering weather of LA. When I ran out of the product, I was so surprised that Yesstyle started carrying the product (for a cheaper price), and immediately got it. It doesn't smudge, doesn't budge, stays on the waterline, and the matte brown shade is a beautiful dark neutral brown that compliments dark Asian eyes.

Never thought I would love a gel/pencil liner more than I love liquid pen liner. Purchasing this was a game changer with my eyeliner game. Will buy more!

my eyelids are super oily so eyeliner usually goes away or smudges everywhere but this eyeliner works so well. i hope they will sell this forever

i got one of these eyeliners in the color mellow coral and i love it! i have monolids, so i've struggled with finding eyeliners that don't smudge everywhere or rub off within a few hours; with the etude house eye primer, this stays put pretty much all day. the mellow coral color is super pretty and lowkey enough that i can use it as a semi-natural everyday liner! the texture is also really soft and easy to apply :)

creamy formula. Nice, natural pink color for the eyes. Can also be used as a lip liner! A little hard to twist out, but nothing unreasonable.

the formula is sooooo soft!! easy to manage and is a great baseline gel eyeliner.