lilybyred - Am9 to Pm9 Survival Colorcara - 5 Colors

Its vertical waterproof, like ROMAND fix mascaras and i love it for oily eyelids and straight laskes. it gives more of a natural look

J’ai commandé la teinte marron de ce mascara . je suis très contente il tient vraiment toute la journée et le marron offre un regards moins dur . Aussi il ne fait pas de paquet , je recommande.

Ich liebe diese Farbe einfach, ich krieg ständig Komplimente und sie hält Bombenfest. Man braucht auf jeden Fall einen guten Mascara Remover, um die ohne Schrubben wieder abzubekommen.

Good and almost oil proof which isn’t the best 😭
it’s really hard to take it off

this is now my fav, the I order the red one, and is amazing for the autumn season. Its easy to take of and it last all day

i love this mascasa, this is my third bottle, the color it’s so pretty and the durability it’s amazing

Okay so I’m going to list everything on here.

Mascaras I have used which did nothing:

Maybelline Sky High
Mac extended play gigablack lash
All of catrice glam doll
Fenty mascara
anastasia beverlyhills mascara
L’Oréal manga doll

the list goes on…

BUT THIS ONE.
I used to love the og one the one and only heroine mascara this is in every Asian girl’s make up bag that is the ride or die. I do have some points I did not like about it tho. Just sunscreen in summer and this mascara are no good pairing u’ll look like a raccoon after 2 hours. But generally the stay is incredible.


NOW LET ME TELL YOU THIS ONE IS INSANE.

I SLEPT IN THIS MASCARA
I CRIED WITH IT
I WAS SUNBATHING WITH OIL ALL OVER MY FACE
I WAS SWIMMING AND DIVING!!!!
I WAS SWEATING WITH IT
I even had the mascara without touchups on for 2 days (things happen)

NO RACCOON EYES
NO FALL OUT
NO BLACK FRECKLES
OR UNDEREYE CREASING PROBLEMS

IT👏F*CKING👏STAYS👏ON.

It has fibers in the mascara (same as heroine).

At first it could seem too thin (consistency wise) but it kinda thickens after a time (air gets in etc)
It drys quickly
leaves no streaks on your upper lid like some other mascaras do (I have combination skin so my eyelids tend to get oily after a few hours). all in all it’s perfect I got 3 colors the black one (#05) it’s straight up black not lowkey brown. It’s black. the brown one(#04) (it’s brown as a tree really recommend it for ppl which want to achieve a more natural make up look it really pulls down and doesn’t seem too much. You cannot really find this natural brown in drugstores, the ones in drugstores seem more auburn rather than brown. Side note I purchased it 2x times just saying. And I got the #02 I thought at first it’s going to be really rosy or rosy like. NO. it’s more of a auburn kinda mascara. really pretty tho. compliments green eyes.

down below (on the left the lilybyred in color #02 on the right heroine Long up Mascara in Color #02.

the Brown from the lilzbyred is a really warm and Deep Brown. the one I uploaded is that Color. also the side by side on the back of my Hand are (left) #02 and (right) #04.

Okay so I’m going to list everything on here.

Mascaras I have used which did nothing:

Maybelline Sky High
Mac extended play gigablack lash
All of catrice glam doll
Fenty mascara
anastasia beverlyhills mascara
L’Oréal manga doll

the list goes on…

BUT THIS ONE.
I used to love the og one the one and only heroine mascara this is in every Asian girl’s make up bag that is the ride or die. I do have some points I did not like about it tho. Just sunscreen in summer and this mascara are no good pairing u’ll look like a raccoon after 2 hours. But generally the stay is incredible.


NOW LET ME TELL YOU THIS ONE IS INSANE.

I SLEPT IN THIS MASCARA
I CRIED WITH IT
I WAS SUNBATHING WITH OIL ALL OVER MY FACE
I WAS SWIMMING AND DIVING!!!!
I WAS SWEATING WITH IT
I even had the mascara without touchups on for 2 days (things happen)

NO RACCOON EYES
NO FALL OUT
NO BLACK FRECKLES
OR UNDEREYE CREASING PROBLEMS

IT👏F*CKING👏STAYS👏ON.

It has fibers in the mascara (same as heroine).

At first it could seem too thin (consistency wise) but it kinda thickens after a time (air gets in etc)
It drys quickly
leaves no streaks on your upper lid like some other mascaras do (I have combination skin so my eyelids tend to get oily after a few hours). all in all it’s perfect I got 3 colors the black one (#05) it’s straight up black not lowkey brown. It’s black. the brown one(#04) (it’s brown as a tree really recommend it for ppl which want to achieve a more natural make up look it really pulls down and doesn’t seem too much. You cannot really find this natural brown in drugstores, the ones in drugstores seem more auburn rather than brown. Side note I purchased it 2x times just saying. And I got the #02 I thought at first it’s going to be really rosy or rosy like. NO. it’s more of a auburn kinda mascara. really pretty tho. compliments green eyes.

down below (on the left the lilybyred in color #02 on the right heroine Long up Mascara in Color #02.

the Brown from the lilzbyred is a really warm and Deep Brown. the one I uploaded is that Color. also the side by side on the back of my Hand are (left) #02 and (right) #04.

Okay so I’m going to list everything on here.

Mascaras I have used which did nothing:

Maybelline Sky High
Mac extended play gigablack lash
All of catrice glam doll
Fenty mascara
anastasia beverlyhills mascara
L’Oréal manga doll

the list goes on…

BUT THIS ONE.
I used to love the og one the one and only heroine mascara this is in every Asian girl’s make up bag that is the ride or die. I do have some points I did not like about it tho. Just sunscreen in summer and this mascara are no good pairing u’ll look like a raccoon after 2 hours. But generally the stay is incredible.


NOW LET ME TELL YOU THIS ONE IS INSANE.

I SLEPT IN THIS MASCARA
I CRIED WITH IT
I WAS SUNBATHING WITH OIL ALL OVER MY FACE
I WAS SWIMMING AND DIVING!!!!
I WAS SWEATING WITH IT
I even had the mascara without touchups on for 2 days (things happen)

NO RACCOON EYES
NO FALL OUT
NO BLACK FRECKLES
OR UNDEREYE CREASING PROBLEMS

IT👏F*CKING👏STAYS👏ON.

It has fibers in the mascara (same as heroine).

At first it could seem too thin (consistency wise) but it kinda thickens after a time (air gets in etc)
It drys quickly
leaves no streaks on your upper lid like some other mascaras do (I have combination skin so my eyelids tend to get oily after a few hours). all in all it’s perfect I got 3 colors the black one (#05) it’s straight up black not lowkey brown. It’s black. the brown one(#04) (it’s brown as a tree really recommend it for ppl which want to achieve a more natural make up look it really pulls down and doesn’t seem too much. You cannot really find this natural brown in drugstores, the ones in drugstores seem more auburn rather than brown. Side note I purchased it 2x times just saying. And I got the #02 I thought at first it’s going to be really rosy or rosy like. NO. it’s more of a auburn kinda mascara. really pretty tho. compliments green eyes.

down below (on the left the lilybyred in color #02 on the right heroine Long up Mascara in Color #02.

the Brown from the lilzbyred is a really warm and Deep Brown. the one I uploaded is that Color. also the side by side on the back of my Hand are (left) #02 and (right) #04.

Okay so I’m going to list everything on here.

Mascaras I have used which did nothing:

Maybelline Sky High
Mac extended play gigablack lash
All of catrice glam doll
Fenty mascara
anastasia beverlyhills mascara
L’Oréal manga doll

the list goes on…

BUT THIS ONE.
I used to love the og one the one and only heroine mascara this is in every Asian girl’s make up bag that is the ride or die. I do have some points I did not like about it tho. Just sunscreen in summer and this mascara are no good pairing u’ll look like a raccoon after 2 hours. But generally the stay is incredible.


NOW LET ME TELL YOU THIS ONE IS INSANE.

I SLEPT IN THIS MASCARA
I CRIED WITH IT
I WAS SUNBATHING WITH OIL ALL OVER MY FACE
I WAS SWIMMING AND DIVING!!!!
I WAS SWEATING WITH IT
I even had the mascara without touchups on for 2 days (things happen)

NO RACCOON EYES
NO FALL OUT
NO BLACK FRECKLES
OR UNDEREYE CREASING PROBLEMS

IT👏F*CKING👏STAYS👏ON.

It has fibers in the mascara (same as heroine).

At first it could seem too thin (consistency wise) but it kinda thickens after a time (air gets in etc)
It drys quickly
leaves no streaks on your upper lid like some other mascaras do (I have combination skin so my eyelids tend to get oily after a few hours). all in all it’s perfect I got 3 colors the black one (#05) it’s straight up black not lowkey brown. It’s black. the brown one(#04) (it’s brown as a tree really recommend it for ppl which want to achieve a more natural make up look it really pulls down and doesn’t seem too much. You cannot really find this natural brown in drugstores, the ones in drugstores seem more auburn rather than brown. Side note I purchased it 2x times just saying. And I got the #02 I thought at first it’s going to be really rosy or rosy like. NO. it’s more of a auburn kinda mascara. really pretty tho. compliments green eyes.

down below (on the left the lilybyred in color #02 on the right heroine Long up Mascara in Color #02.

the Brown from the lilzbyred is a really warm and Deep Brown. the one I uploaded is that Color. also the side by side on the back of my Hand are (left) #02 and (right) #04.

Okay so I’m going to list everything on here.

Mascaras I have used which did nothing:

Maybelline Sky High
Mac extended play gigablack lash
All of catrice glam doll
Fenty mascara
anastasia beverlyhills mascara
L’Oréal manga doll

the list goes on…

BUT THIS ONE.
I used to love the og one the one and only heroine mascara this is in every Asian girl’s make up bag that is the ride or die. I do have some points I did not like about it tho. Just sunscreen in summer and this mascara are no good pairing u’ll look like a raccoon after 2 hours. But generally the stay is incredible.


NOW LET ME TELL YOU THIS ONE IS INSANE.

I SLEPT IN THIS MASCARA
I CRIED WITH IT
I WAS SUNBATHING WITH OIL ALL OVER MY FACE
I WAS SWIMMING AND DIVING!!!!
I WAS SWEATING WITH IT
I even had the mascara without touchups on for 2 days (things happen)

NO RACCOON EYES
NO FALL OUT
NO BLACK FRECKLES
OR UNDEREYE CREASING PROBLEMS

IT👏F*CKING👏STAYS👏ON.

It has fibers in the mascara (same as heroine).

At first it could seem too thin (consistency wise) but it kinda thickens after a time (air gets in etc)
It drys quickly
leaves no streaks on your upper lid like some other mascaras do (I have combination skin so my eyelids tend to get oily after a few hours). all in all it’s perfect I got 3 colors the black one (#05) it’s straight up black not lowkey brown. It’s black. the brown one(#04) (it’s brown as a tree really recommend it for ppl which want to achieve a more natural make up look it really pulls down and doesn’t seem too much. You cannot really find this natural brown in drugstores, the ones in drugstores seem more auburn rather than brown. Side note I purchased it 2x times just saying. And I got the #02 I thought at first it’s going to be really rosy or rosy like. NO. it’s more of a auburn kinda mascara. really pretty tho. compliments green eyes.

down below (on the left the lilybyred in color #02 on the right heroine Long up Mascara in Color #02.

the Brown from the lilzbyred is a really warm and Deep Brown. the one I uploaded is that Color. also the side by side on the back of my Hand are (left) #02 and (right) #04.

Okay so I’m going to list everything on here.

Mascaras I have used which did nothing:

Maybelline Sky High
Mac extended play gigablack lash
All of catrice glam doll
Fenty mascara
anastasia beverlyhills mascara
L’Oréal manga doll

the list goes on…

BUT THIS ONE.
I used to love the og one the one and only heroine mascara this is in every Asian girl’s make up bag that is the ride or die. I do have some points I did not like about it tho. Just sunscreen in summer and this mascara are no good pairing u’ll look like a raccoon after 2 hours. But generally the stay is incredible.


NOW LET ME TELL YOU THIS ONE IS INSANE.

I SLEPT IN THIS MASCARA
I CRIED WITH IT
I WAS SUNBATHING WITH OIL ALL OVER MY FACE
I WAS SWIMMING AND DIVING!!!!
I WAS SWEATING WITH IT
I even had the mascara without touchups on for 2 days (things happen)

NO RACCOON EYES
NO FALL OUT
NO BLACK FRECKLES
OR UNDEREYE CREASING PROBLEMS

IT👏F*CKING👏STAYS👏ON.

It has fibers in the mascara (same as heroine).

At first it could seem too thin (consistency wise) but it kinda thickens after a time (air gets in etc)
It drys quickly
leaves no streaks on your upper lid like some other mascaras do (I have combination skin so my eyelids tend to get oily after a few hours). all in all it’s perfect I got 3 colors the black one (#05) it’s straight up black not lowkey brown. It’s black. the brown one(#04) (it’s brown as a tree really recommend it for ppl which want to achieve a more natural make up look it really pulls down and doesn’t seem too much. You cannot really find this natural brown in drugstores, the ones in drugstores seem more auburn rather than brown. Side note I purchased it 2x times just saying. And I got the #02 I thought at first it’s going to be really rosy or rosy like. NO. it’s more of a auburn kinda mascara. really pretty tho. compliments green eyes.

down below (on the left the lilybyred in color #02 on the right heroine Long up Mascara in Color #02.

the Brown from the lilzbyred is a really warm and Deep Brown. the one I uploaded is that Color. also the side by side on the back of my Hand are (left) #02 and (right) #04.

Okay so I’m going to list everything on here.

Mascaras I have used which did nothing:

Maybelline Sky High
Mac extended play gigablack lash
All of catrice glam doll
Fenty mascara
anastasia beverlyhills mascara
L’Oréal manga doll

the list goes on…

BUT THIS ONE.
I used to love the og one the one and only heroine mascara this is in every Asian girl’s make up bag that is the ride or die. I do have some points I did not like about it tho. Just sunscreen in summer and this mascara are no good pairing u’ll look like a raccoon after 2 hours. But generally the stay is incredible.


NOW LET ME TELL YOU THIS ONE IS INSANE.

I SLEPT IN THIS MASCARA
I CRIED WITH IT
I WAS SUNBATHING WITH OIL ALL OVER MY FACE
I WAS SWIMMING AND DIVING!!!!
I WAS SWEATING WITH IT
I even had the mascara without touchups on for 2 days (things happen)

NO RACCOON EYES
NO FALL OUT
NO BLACK FRECKLES
OR UNDEREYE CREASING PROBLEMS

IT👏F*CKING👏STAYS👏ON.

It has fibers in the mascara (same as heroine).

At first it could seem too thin (consistency wise) but it kinda thickens after a time (air gets in etc)
It drys quickly
leaves no streaks on your upper lid like some other mascaras do (I have combination skin so my eyelids tend to get oily after a few hours). all in all it’s perfect I got 3 colors the black one (#05) it’s straight up black not lowkey brown. It’s black. the brown one(#04) (it’s brown as a tree really recommend it for ppl which want to achieve a more natural make up look it really pulls down and doesn’t seem too much. You cannot really find this natural brown in drugstores, the ones in drugstores seem more auburn rather than brown. Side note I purchased it 2x times just saying. And I got the #02 I thought at first it’s going to be really rosy or rosy like. NO. it’s more of a auburn kinda mascara. really pretty tho. compliments green eyes.

down below (on the left the lilybyred in color #02 on the right heroine Long up Mascara in Color #02.

the Brown from the lilzbyred is a really warm and Deep Brown. the one I uploaded is that Color. also the side by side on the back of my Hand are (left) #02 and (right) #04.

just wanted to add the black one too. the other ones are over this one. Oh and about getting it off

if You have a balm apply it on top of ur lashes and let this marinade, it needs to. Trust me.

oil cleansing? put a few drops on your lash line and then get ur hands oily a few pumps in ur hand and rub gently as if your fingers are a mascara wand it will do the trick it’s not worse than the heroine one. side note if your looking for another mascara (black) that’s also really good I really recommend the Kill lash superproof mascara volume curling from Clio (black wand with red streaks)

just wanted to add the black one too. the other ones are over this one. Oh and about getting it off

if You have a balm apply it on top of ur lashes and let this marinade, it needs to. Trust me.

oil cleansing? put a few drops on your lash line and then get ur hands oily a few pumps in ur hand and rub gently as if your fingers are a mascara wand it will do the trick it’s not worse than the heroine one. side note if your looking for another mascara (black) that’s also really good I really recommend the Kill lash superproof mascara volume curling from Clio (black wand with red streaks)

So satisfied of this purchase, it’s been about 2 years that I buy these products. They stay on my lashes all day long without smudge under the eyes, and the color give such a natural look. But I m a bit sad the color ginger brown was discontinued.

I like the etude mascara buttt i feel like its a little too heavy and waxy, hard to remove, if you're looking for an waterproof mascara but lighter this is it!! its very light on the lashes, easier to remove and it gives that natural fluffy look! it does hold up all day and it doesn't clump at all, would definitely recommend it and repurchase it<3

this is the brown one, it looks good but its not as light as I thought it would be

second time I’ve purchased this mascara it’s my all time favourite and my everyday use

This mascara is the only one I know that holds my lashes in place. It's incredibly long-lasting and has beautiful color.

I’ve struggled my entire adult life to find a mascara that doesn’t run. I have Tourette’s Syndrome, and because of this, I blink my eyes really hard all day long. No matter what mascara I have used- big, expensive, waterproof US brands, it’s always under my eyes. I bought this in brown, and the matching eyeliner, and it’s stays on so so well, and it’s not running under my eyes at all. Thoroughly impressed and I will buy this forever as long as it’s made! Thank you for solving my life long makeup issue!

Loving the Lilybyred Am9 to Pm9 Survival Colorcara! It stays all day without smudging, the color is vibrant, and it really makes my lashes pop

I have shade no.02. It’s a burgundy red color. It looks very good on lashes and has a nice staying power. I recommend!!ෆ

I have shade no.02. It’s a burgundy red color. It looks very good on lashes and has a nice staying power. I recommend!!ෆ

The mascara is thick and even visible on dark lashes.
It looks very beautiful when combined with blue eyeshadow.